The Wiki for Tale 6 is in read-only mode and is available for archival and reference purposes only. Please visit the current Tale 11 Wiki in the meantime.

If you have any issues with this Wiki, please post in #wiki-editing on Discord or contact Brad in-game.

Difference between revisions of "Monument of Architecture"

From ATITD6
Jump to navigationJump to search
 
(152 intermediate revisions by 31 users not shown)
Line 3: Line 3:
  
 
=Monument Location =
 
=Monument Location =
Desert of Shades - 500, 3350
+
-500, 3350 Desert of Shades - '''Built and ready for support''' - '''''The Monument site IS the Pyramid'''''
  
= Test Ideas =
+
= Challenge Ideas =
[http://www.atitd.org/wiki/tale6/Test_of_Magnificent_Gardens Test of Magnificent Gardens]
+
Please add your name to the challenge you'd like to have. Please do not add other players names.  Do not let the comments dissuade you from any particular test.  Please read them and make an informed decision.  
== Supporters ==
 
  
=== Oracle ===
 
Darkfyre<br>
 
McArine
 
  
=== Sage ===
+
[[Test of Three Kingdoms]]
Ruby
+
*Off of the table, too much work...not enough time (per Pluribus) - Darkfyre
Renard
 
Morendo
 
KebiRoz
 
Kalmkitty
 
GHawkins
 
toothless
 
blueshift
 
Hounddog
 
Larame
 
  
=== Master ===
+
[[Test of Magnificent Gardens]]
Rhosymedre
+
*The mechanics of this test are interesting, but this sounds more like an Art test - Darkfyre
Mattphat
+
*I vote for this one because it reminds me of the Hanging Gardens of Babylon which will add something truly different to the discipline. In my mind this is more architecture and engineering than art so I am not worried about going astray. My only worry is the requirement for interaction to fill the garden with water and fertiliser (up to every hour is mentioned), it would be nice if there was a way to reduce this as even if you get your guild to help you every hour just isn't feasible. Perhaps a larger hopper, a connection to an aqueduct, or use of extra concentrated fertiliser? There is also no comment on what happens to the garden after the garden passes, perhaps it could be frozen in time whilst in bloom so it can be shown off for forever more? - Mattphat
GammaBird
+
*I like this one, but agree with mattphatt about frequency of filling water and fertiliser. I would suggest 12 hours, similar to Plantation. Also agree that once passed it should stand as a monument to the growers craft - Mariamom
Bessodia
+
**Votes: kalmkitty, cate, mattphat, Rhosymedre, Mariamom
  
=== Scribe ===
+
[[Test of the Deep Mine]]
Ariella Zuvun
+
*Test of the Deep Mine and Hand of Ra have almost identical mechanics, but this is my vote for final test. - Darkfyre
 +
**Votes: Darkfyre, Larame,toothless, Donk79, Morendo, TheMazeEcho
  
=== Journeyman ===
+
[[Hand of Ra]] - (Pluribus' current pick) '''''*Selected Challenge*'''''
Andyhotep
+
*Test of the Deep Mine and Hand of Ra have almost identical mechanics. - Darkfyre
Brunhilda
+
* I vote for this one, but there is confusing wording [also on Deep mine]. By the wording on the wiki, if I build the tallest on Sunday morning, I can prevent passes as my tower is less than 2 days old and the previous tower is no longer the tallest. I don't like that part. I think passes should be after 48 hours, not weekly. Or weekly passes, but no deadline on when to build. (agree; Samisotet)
Oompaw
+
* It's an interesting idea, and I prefer this over Test of the Deep Mine, but it seems essentially the same as obelisk with the addition of the potential for collapse - Mattphat.
 +
**Votes: Yendor, kalmkitty, Samisotet, Renard, tamb
  
=== Prentice ===
+
[[User:Porthos/ArchitectureTestRebirth | The Pylon of Rebirth]] - (Pluribus likes this one too)
Eugenius Risa
+
*Good mechanics, but appears to be a long and drawn out test - Darkfyre
 
+
*I like this idea, but I have a few concerns - I have placed a few possible suggestions on the test page discussion- Blueshift
=== Student ===
+
*Great suggestions Blueshift.  Everyone is quite welcome to edit in improvements/ideas on it - Porthos
 +
**Votes: Eugenius, Porthos, Blueshift, atomadam2
  
 +
== Supporters ==
  
 +
{|class=wikitable
 +
| Report on supporters:|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
 +
|-
 +
| Pharaoh's Oracle|| 1 supporting|| 1 confirmed.||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
 +
|-
 +
|||*Darkfyre|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
 +
|-
 +
| Sage|| 2 supporting|| 2 confirmed.||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
 +
|-
 +
|||*Fuzz|| *McArine|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
 +
|-
 +
| Master|| 4 supporting|| 4 confirmed.||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
 +
|-
 +
|||*Ruby|| *Larame|| *Renard|| *Wampak|||||||||||||||||||||||||
 +
|-
 +
| Scribe|| 8 supporting|| 8 confirmed.|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
 +
|-
 +
|||*Ariella|| *Luan|| *Sabina|| *YendorsSlave|| *bcoastaldawn|| *emeraldlily|| *Karush||*Morendo|||||||||||||||||
 +
|-
 +
| Journeyman|| 16 supporting|| 16 confirmed.||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
 +
|-
 +
|||*Annuminas|| *Bessodia|| *Brunhilda|| *Kalmkitty|| *KebiRoz|| *Rhosymedre|| *cate|| *Amon-Sul|| *Aseto|| *Balthazarr|| *GammaBird|| *Oompaw|| *Robby|| *TheMazeEcho|| *Yendor|| *atomadam2
 +
|-
 +
| Prentice|| 32 supporting|| 32 confirmed.||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
 +
|-
 +
|||*Arwa|| *Astia|| *Avanya|| *Baltharina|| *Handsome|| *Heterika|| *MissBarbara|| *Neas|| *Wishes|| *Ninfa|| *Panyea|| *Rosenfeuer|| *arnika|| *nikara|| *tamb|| *Alkhar
 +
|-
 +
|||*Augir|| *Blueshift|| *Donk79|| *GHawkins|| *Honasha|| *Hounddog|| *MrB|| *Nebamon|| *Ofalot|| *OneBanana|| *Pascalito|| *Porthos|| *Squill|| *Zhukuram|| *herberti|| *mattphat
 +
|-
 +
| Student|| 64 supporting|| 64 confirmed.||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
 +
|-
 +
|||*Ami-Rana|| *Asheara|| *Aubery|| *CherryBlossom|| *Chet|| *DustiTwister|| *Etma|| *Kyline|| *Lizzi|| *Lukeera|| *Maata|| *Mariamom|| *Misty|| *Mitsuko|| *Nitocris|| *Peacefulness
 +
|-
 +
|||*ReddRuby|| *Risa|| *Sakura54|| *Samisotet|| *ShebaNezbia|| *SinDrome|| *SleepyKitty|| *Starfyre|| *Tashienna|| *Ulah|| *Xasis|| *ella|| *ellorin|| *joliet|| *kanara|| *klynn
 +
|-
 +
|||*kuupid|| *sake|| *windingo|| *Crashley|| *AlaricRa|| *Arahgon|| *Arden|| *Bartram|| *Bryce|| *Denebo|| *Eros|| *Hemptwister|| *Jazkar|| *Markanthony|| *Maximus|| *Mektos
 +
|-
 +
|||*Milythael|| *PetrusIV|| *PtolemyVII|| *Qwu|| *Rabble|| *Sithid|| *Sonnenfeuer|| *Sparky|| *Strutter|| *Tibere|| *amron|| *badkitty|| *farmer|| *hd-jr|| *toothless|| *zydhek
 +
|-
 +
|}
  
 
== Materials needed ==
 
== Materials needed ==
Line 52: Line 83:
 
{{ResResource|Copper Foil|7000|7000}}  
 
{{ResResource|Copper Foil|7000|7000}}  
 
{{ResResource|Gold Foil|7000|7000}}  
 
{{ResResource|Gold Foil|7000|7000}}  
{{ResResource|Silver Foil|3072|7000}} - Pledged by GammaBird
+
{{ResResource|Silver Foil|7000|7000}}
{{ResResource|Steel Foil|7000|7000}} - zFree
+
{{ResResource|Steel Foil|7000|7000}}
{{ResResource|Lead Foil|0|7000}} - Pledged by KalmKitty
+
{{ResResource|Lead Foil|7000|7000}}
{{ResResource|Tin Foil|0|7000}}
+
{{ResResource|Tin Foil|7000|7000}}
{{ResResource|Titanium Foil|2000|7000}} - Pledged by GHawkins
+
{{ResResource|Titanium Foil|7000|7000}}
{{ResResource|Thoths Metal Foil|0|7000}} - Pledged by cate
+
{{ResResource|Thoths Metal Foil|7000|7000}}  
{{ResResource|Metal Blue Foil|0|7000}} - zFree is working on this, iron donations are welcome.
+
{{ResResource|Metal Blue Foil|7000|7000}}
{{ResResource|OCtec's Alloy Foil|7000|7000}} - zFree
+
{{ResResource|Octec's Alloy Foil|7000|7000}}  
{{ResResource|Moon Steel Foil|1000|7000}} - Pledged by cate
+
{{ResResource|Moon Steel Foil|7000|7000}}
{{ResResource|Water Metal Foil|0|7000}}
+
{{ResResource|Water Metal Foil|7000|7000}}
{{ResResource|Aluminium Foil|0|7000}} -Pledged by Tamb
+
{{ResResource|Aluminium Foil|7000|7000}}
{{ResResource|Small Stone Blocks|3579|25000}}
+
{{ResResource|Small Stone Blocks|25000|25000}}  
 
{{ResResource|Huge Diamond|7|7}}
 
{{ResResource|Huge Diamond|7|7}}
 
{{ResResource|Huge Quartz|7|7 }}
 
{{ResResource|Huge Quartz|7|7 }}
{{ResResource|Huge Emerald|0|7 }}
+
{{ResResource|Huge Emerald|7|7 }}
 
{{ResResource|Huge Opal|7|7 }}
 
{{ResResource|Huge Opal|7|7 }}
 
{{ResResource|Huge Ruby |7 |7 }}
 
{{ResResource|Huge Ruby |7 |7 }}
{{ResResource|Huge Sapphire|5|7 }}
+
{{ResResource|Huge Sapphire|7|7 }}
{{ResResource|Topaz|7|7 }}
+
{{ResResource|Huge Topaz|7|7 }}
 
{{ResResource|Jade|35|35}} - Stashed by Morendo
 
{{ResResource|Jade|35|35}} - Stashed by Morendo
 
{{ResResource|Canary Granite|21|21}} - Stashed by Morendo
 
{{ResResource|Canary Granite|21|21}} - Stashed by Morendo
{{ResResource|Blood Granite|0|21}} - PLedged by cate and Mattphat
+
{{ResResource|Blood Granite|21|21}} - Pledged by cate and Mattphat
 
{{ResResource|Firerock|14|14}} - Stashed by Morendo
 
{{ResResource|Firerock|14|14}} - Stashed by Morendo
 
{{ResResource|Onyx|14|14}} - Stashed by Morendo
 
{{ResResource|Onyx|14|14}} - Stashed by Morendo

Latest revision as of 15:45, 4 September 2015

Guild Location

River Plains @ 1549, 2863

Monument Location

-500, 3350 Desert of Shades - Built and ready for support - The Monument site IS the Pyramid

Challenge Ideas

Please add your name to the challenge you'd like to have. Please do not add other players names. Do not let the comments dissuade you from any particular test. Please read them and make an informed decision.


Test of Three Kingdoms

  • Off of the table, too much work...not enough time (per Pluribus) - Darkfyre

Test of Magnificent Gardens

  • The mechanics of this test are interesting, but this sounds more like an Art test - Darkfyre
  • I vote for this one because it reminds me of the Hanging Gardens of Babylon which will add something truly different to the discipline. In my mind this is more architecture and engineering than art so I am not worried about going astray. My only worry is the requirement for interaction to fill the garden with water and fertiliser (up to every hour is mentioned), it would be nice if there was a way to reduce this as even if you get your guild to help you every hour just isn't feasible. Perhaps a larger hopper, a connection to an aqueduct, or use of extra concentrated fertiliser? There is also no comment on what happens to the garden after the garden passes, perhaps it could be frozen in time whilst in bloom so it can be shown off for forever more? - Mattphat
  • I like this one, but agree with mattphatt about frequency of filling water and fertiliser. I would suggest 12 hours, similar to Plantation. Also agree that once passed it should stand as a monument to the growers craft - Mariamom
    • Votes: kalmkitty, cate, mattphat, Rhosymedre, Mariamom

Test of the Deep Mine

  • Test of the Deep Mine and Hand of Ra have almost identical mechanics, but this is my vote for final test. - Darkfyre
    • Votes: Darkfyre, Larame,toothless, Donk79, Morendo, TheMazeEcho

Hand of Ra - (Pluribus' current pick) *Selected Challenge*

  • Test of the Deep Mine and Hand of Ra have almost identical mechanics. - Darkfyre
  • I vote for this one, but there is confusing wording [also on Deep mine]. By the wording on the wiki, if I build the tallest on Sunday morning, I can prevent passes as my tower is less than 2 days old and the previous tower is no longer the tallest. I don't like that part. I think passes should be after 48 hours, not weekly. Or weekly passes, but no deadline on when to build. (agree; Samisotet)
  • It's an interesting idea, and I prefer this over Test of the Deep Mine, but it seems essentially the same as obelisk with the addition of the potential for collapse - Mattphat.
    • Votes: Yendor, kalmkitty, Samisotet, Renard, tamb

The Pylon of Rebirth - (Pluribus likes this one too)

  • Good mechanics, but appears to be a long and drawn out test - Darkfyre
  • I like this idea, but I have a few concerns - I have placed a few possible suggestions on the test page discussion- Blueshift
  • Great suggestions Blueshift. Everyone is quite welcome to edit in improvements/ideas on it - Porthos
    • Votes: Eugenius, Porthos, Blueshift, atomadam2

Supporters

Report on supporters:
Pharaoh's Oracle 1 supporting 1 confirmed.
*Darkfyre
Sage 2 supporting 2 confirmed.
*Fuzz *McArine
Master 4 supporting 4 confirmed.
*Ruby *Larame *Renard *Wampak
Scribe 8 supporting 8 confirmed.
*Ariella *Luan *Sabina *YendorsSlave *bcoastaldawn *emeraldlily *Karush *Morendo
Journeyman 16 supporting 16 confirmed.
*Annuminas *Bessodia *Brunhilda *Kalmkitty *KebiRoz *Rhosymedre *cate *Amon-Sul *Aseto *Balthazarr *GammaBird *Oompaw *Robby *TheMazeEcho *Yendor *atomadam2
Prentice 32 supporting 32 confirmed.
*Arwa *Astia *Avanya *Baltharina *Handsome *Heterika *MissBarbara *Neas *Wishes *Ninfa *Panyea *Rosenfeuer *arnika *nikara *tamb *Alkhar
*Augir *Blueshift *Donk79 *GHawkins *Honasha *Hounddog *MrB *Nebamon *Ofalot *OneBanana *Pascalito *Porthos *Squill *Zhukuram *herberti *mattphat
Student 64 supporting 64 confirmed.
*Ami-Rana *Asheara *Aubery *CherryBlossom *Chet *DustiTwister *Etma *Kyline *Lizzi *Lukeera *Maata *Mariamom *Misty *Mitsuko *Nitocris *Peacefulness
*ReddRuby *Risa *Sakura54 *Samisotet *ShebaNezbia *SinDrome *SleepyKitty *Starfyre *Tashienna *Ulah *Xasis *ella *ellorin *joliet *kanara *klynn
*kuupid *sake *windingo *Crashley *AlaricRa *Arahgon *Arden *Bartram *Bryce *Denebo *Eros *Hemptwister *Jazkar *Markanthony *Maximus *Mektos
*Milythael *PetrusIV *PtolemyVII *Qwu *Rabble *Sithid *Sonnenfeuer *Sparky *Strutter *Tibere *amron *badkitty *farmer *hd-jr *toothless *zydhek

Materials needed

  • These are the updated materials required for the Monument of Architecture
block
Ra's Brilliant Compound Extract
100
/
100
(0)
100%
- The power of the God
Copper Foil
7000
/
7000
(0)
100%
Gold Foil
7000
/
7000
(0)
100%
Silver Foil
7000
/
7000
(0)
100%
Steel Foil
7000
/
7000
(0)
100%
Lead Foil
7000
/
7000
(0)
100%
Tin Foil
7000
/
7000
(0)
100%
Titanium Foil
7000
/
7000
(0)
100%
Thoths Metal Foil
7000
/
7000
(0)
100%
Metal Blue Foil
7000
/
7000
(0)
100%
Octec's Alloy Foil
7000
/
7000
(0)
100%
Moon Steel Foil
7000
/
7000
(0)
100%
Water Metal Foil
7000
/
7000
(0)
100%
Aluminium Foil
7000
/
7000
(0)
100%
Small Stone Blocks
25000
/
25000
(0)
100%
Huge Diamond
7
/
7
(0)
100%
Huge Quartz
7
/
7
(0)
100%
Huge Emerald
7
/
7
(0)
100%
Huge Opal
7
/
7
(0)
100%
Huge Ruby
7
/
7
(0)
100%
Huge Sapphire
7
/
7
(0)
100%
Huge Topaz
7
/
7
(0)
100%
Jade
35
/
35
(0)
100%
- Stashed by Morendo
Canary Granite
21
/
21
(0)
100%
- Stashed by Morendo
Blood Granite
21
/
21
(0)
100%
- Pledged by cate and Mattphat
Firerock
14
/
14
(0)
100%
- Stashed by Morendo
Onyx
14
/
14
(0)
100%
- Stashed by Morendo
Angel Stone
7
/
7
(0)
100%
- Stashed by Morendo
Puzzle Granite
7
/
7
(0)
100%
- Stashed by Morendo
block